HIDDEN GEMS AND UNDERRATED RECORDS, VOL. I

I’ve been working on a lot of brackets lately as we’ve just launched the Bracket Series on the Maine Hardcore Media YouTube channel (I’ll have the inaugural episode with Courtney from Retract and Derek from Retract and Defeater at the bottom of this article), and it’s occasioned me to start reflecting on and re-visiting albums from the past, and to think more about their place in the zeitgeist of the time in which they were released and where they stand in the dialogue of today. Such an exercise has thus naturally led me to records I think are underrated in the discourse for one reason or another, and I decided to start a series where I would feature a handful of these records with a little discussion of their contents and why—if you aren’t familiar with the record—you should check it out. And if you are, then you’re an Elite Ball-Knower, and you can bask in your good taste. So, without further ado, our selections for the Underrated Records series, starting with…

The_Network-Bishop Kent Manning (2009)

I was deeply saddened to hear the news recently that bassist Matthew Bennett had passed away in a tragic automobile accident at the young age of 44. While my condolences go out to his friends and family, his talent endures on record with the exceptional Bishop Kent Manning. Produced by Kurt Ballou at Godcity Studios, the record is based on an original short story by the New England band’s guitarist Kevin Howley; as guitarist Pete Marr states, “the movie version goes like this… televangelist on his deathbed reconsiders the existence of God and questions his methods of deception. We used the short story as a jumping off point with each song capturing different facets of the main character, Bishop Kent Manning.” Both Coalesce (Ox) and Burnt by the Sun (Heart of Darkness) also released records this same year, reminding everyone why they’re legends, and this record sits comfortably alongside those two—which, for the record, I rank as those respective bands’ best albums. If you like chaotic, visceral, misanthropic metalcore, this is the album for you. They really don’t make `em like this anymore.

And speaking of Ox…


Coalesce-Ox (2009)

Not only does Ox feature some of the band’s best songwriting, but there are some really interesting moves they make on top of that that add to the atmosphere of this record feeling like some weird and unsettling record recorded deep in the swamplands in the time of O Brother, Where Art Thou? See, for instance, the bluesman opening of “Wild Ox Moan,” or the chain-gang chant during the bridge on “In My Wake, For My Own.”

Architects-Hollow Crown (2009)

Staying in 2009 for our final selection here, it might seem a bit odd to call an album by one of the biggest metalcore bands in the world underrated, but I feel like most contemporary fans of the band think their discography starts at Holy Hell, whereas other fans of the band either gravitate toward their middle era or the early skronky stuff. With the largely-forgotten follow-up to Hollow Crown where they tried a Bring Me the Horizon with The Here and Now (I say this jokingly because for a while Architects were always putting out some adjacent version of what BMTH was doing a year after: Counting Your Blessings (2006)-Ruin (2007); Suicide Season (with a Sam Carter feature!, 2008)-Hollow Crown (2009); There Is a Hell Believe Me I've Seen It. There Is a Heaven Let's Keep It a Secret. (2010) -The Here and Now (2011)) excepted, this seems to be the least-discussed of their records, and that’s a shame because not only is it their best, it’s one of the best metalcore albums of all time. No one has been able to capture this synthesis of aching melancholy and melodicism, crushing heaviness, and freneticism in this way before or since.

The Maine Hardcore Media Bracket Series, Episode One: Crowning the Best 2010s Hardcore Band

Next
Next

PLATINUM MOSH, VOL. III